The Role of Technology in India’s Healthcare Revolution

Introduction

India’s healthcare system, with its vast scale and diverse challenges, is undergoing a profound transformation, driven largely by technological innovations. This transformation is not merely about modernizing healthcare delivery in urban settings but also about bridging the significant gaps in rural health infrastructure. Telemedicine, artificial intelligence (AI), digital health records, and wearable technologies are key drivers in this healthcare revolution, promising to enhance accessibility, quality of care, and preventive health measures. Despite these advancements, the adoption of technology in India’s healthcare system, particularly in rural areas, presents unique challenges.

This article explores the critical role of technology in revolutionizing healthcare in India by focusing on three main areas: the contributions of telemedicine, AI, and digital health records to healthcare access; the challenges of implementing technological solutions in rural areas; and the growing potential of wearable technology in preventive healthcare.

The Role of Telemedicine, AI, and Digital Health Records in Improving Healthcare Access

1. Telemedicine: Breaking Barriers to Healthcare Access

Telemedicine refers to the use of telecommunications technology to provide healthcare services remotely. In a country like India, where vast geographical distances and inadequate healthcare infrastructure often hinder access to timely and quality medical care, telemedicine has emerged as a game changer.

India’s vast and diverse population—more than two-thirds of which lives in rural areas—often faces significant challenges in accessing healthcare. This is particularly true in remote villages where there is a dearth of specialists and medical facilities. The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted the importance of telemedicine, with consultations moving online and patients receiving care without traveling to overwhelmed urban hospitals. The Indian government’s approval of telemedicine guidelines in 2020 further accelerated its adoption, allowing healthcare professionals to consult and treat patients through virtual platforms.

Impact of Telemedicine:

– Access to Specialists: Through telemedicine platforms, patients in remote areas can access consultations with specialists in urban centers, improving early diagnosis and treatment.

– Reduced Travel and Costs: Telemedicine eliminates the need for patients to travel long distances to access care, significantly reducing costs and making healthcare more affordable for low-income families.

– Continuity of Care: Regular follow-ups and consultations can be conducted virtually, ensuring continuity of care, especially for patients with chronic conditions like diabetes and hypertension.

– E-ICU Services: Telemedicine also enables remote monitoring of critical patients through E-ICU setups, where doctors can oversee ICU patients from centralized control rooms in urban hospitals. This helps bridge the shortage of ICU specialists in smaller towns.

2. Artificial Intelligence (AI): Enhancing Diagnosis and Treatment

AI is revolutionizing the way healthcare is delivered by automating tasks, enhancing diagnostics, and improving personalized treatment plans. In India, where there is a shortage of trained healthcare professionals, AI can play a crucial role in scaling up services, particularly in areas such as medical imaging, disease prediction, and data analytics.

AI in Diagnostics:

AI algorithms can analyse medical images such as X-rays, CT scans, and MRIs to detect anomalies like tumours, fractures, and infections with high accuracy. AI-powered diagnostic tools are particularly valuable in India, where there is a significant shortage of radiologists. For instance, AI applications can assist doctors in identifying early-stage diseases, such as cancer, tuberculosis, or diabetic retinopathy, even in resource-constrained settings.

Predictive Analytics:

AI-powered predictive models can analyse large datasets of patient information, including medical history, genetic data, and lifestyle factors, to predict disease risks. This enables healthcare providers to intervene early, improving patient outcomes and reducing healthcare costs. Predictive models are particularly useful in managing chronic diseases, such as cardiovascular disease and diabetes, which have a high prevalence in India.

Personalized Treatment:

AI also contributes to personalized medicine by tailoring treatment plans based on a patient’s unique genetic makeup and health data. In India, where personalized care is often inaccessible to a large segment of the population, AI can democratize access to individualized healthcare.

3. Digital Health Records: Streamlining Patient Data and Enhancing Continuity of Care

Digital health records, also known as electronic health records (EHRs), are another transformative technology in India’s healthcare system. EHRs allow healthcare providers to store and access patient data in a centralized, digital format, improving the efficiency of care and enabling better coordination between healthcare providers.

Benefits of Digital Health Records:

– Accessibility: EHRs enable doctors to access a patient’s complete medical history, lab reports, and treatment plans, regardless of where the patient is located. This is particularly useful for patients who visit multiple healthcare facilities or specialists.

– Improved Diagnosis and Treatment: Access to comprehensive medical data allows healthcare providers to make more informed decisions, leading to better diagnosis and treatment outcomes.

– Efficiency in Healthcare Delivery: EHRs eliminate the need for patients to carry paper records and reduce administrative burdens on healthcare providers, allowing them to focus more on patient care.

– Government Initiatives: The Indian government’s National Digital Health Mission (NDHM) aims to create a unified digital health ecosystem by promoting the use of EHRs and health IDs. This initiative could play a pivotal role in standardizing healthcare records across the country and making healthcare more inclusive.

Challenges of Implementing Tech Solutions in Rural Areas

Despite the enormous potential of technology to revolutionize healthcare in India, implementing these solutions in rural areas comes with a unique set of challenges.

1. Infrastructure Constraints

One of the primary barriers to the adoption of telemedicine and other digital health solutions in rural India is the lack of reliable infrastructure. Many villages face challenges such as:

– Poor Internet Connectivity: Telemedicine and digital health records require stable internet connections, but many rural areas still lack reliable broadband access. Although government initiatives such as BharatNet aim to improve rural internet connectivity, progress is slow, limiting the reach of digital healthcare services.

– Unreliable Electricity Supply: Frequent power outages in rural areas can disrupt the functioning of telemedicine services and other technology-driven healthcare initiatives.

– Lack of Healthcare Facilities: Even with technological advancements, rural healthcare infrastructure remains inadequate. Many villages do not have primary healthcare centers, and where they do exist, they are often understaffed and lack basic medical equipment.

2. Digital Literacy and Awareness

For technology-driven healthcare solutions to be effective, both healthcare providers and patients must be comfortable using digital platforms. In rural areas, however, digital literacy is often low, and many patients are unfamiliar with telemedicine platforms, mobile health apps, and EHR systems.

– Lack of Training for Healthcare Providers: Many rural healthcare workers, including doctors and nurses, are not trained in using telemedicine platforms or managing digital health records, which can hinder the adoption of these technologies.

– Patient Reluctance: Patients in rural areas, particularly the elderly, may be hesitant to adopt digital health solutions due to unfamiliarity with technology or distrust in remote consultations.

3. Cultural and Social Barriers

Cultural beliefs and social norms can also pose barriers to the adoption of technology-driven healthcare solutions in rural India. For example:

– Preference for In-Person Consultations: Many rural patients still prefer face-to-face consultations with doctors and may not trust telemedicine consultations, especially for serious health issues.

– Gender Disparities: In some regions, women may face restrictions on accessing healthcare due to patriarchal norms, limiting their ability to use telemedicine services or wearable health technologies.

4. Affordability and Accessibility

Although telemedicine and digital health solutions can reduce the cost of healthcare in the long term, the initial investment in technology can be a barrier for low-income families in rural areas. The cost of purchasing smartphones, tablets, or wearable devices may be prohibitive for many households.

Moreover, while urban populations may have easy access to telemedicine apps, rural populations often rely on public healthcare services, which may not yet have integrated telemedicine and digital health platforms into their operations.

The Potential of Wearable Technology in Preventive Healthcare

Wearable technology, such as fitness trackers, smartwatches, and wearable sensors, is playing an increasingly important role in preventive healthcare. These devices can monitor a wide range of health metrics, such as heart rate, blood pressure, and physical activity, enabling users to track their health in real time. In India, where preventive healthcare is becoming a growing priority due to the rising burden of chronic diseases, wearable technology offers significant potential.

1. Monitoring Chronic Conditions

India faces a growing burden of non-communicable diseases (NCDs), such as cardiovascular diseases, diabetes, and hypertension. Wearable devices can help patients monitor their vital signs and track health metrics in real time, enabling early detection of anomalies and better management of chronic conditions. For example, a patient with hypertension can use a wearable device to monitor their blood pressure throughout the day and take immediate action if it rises above a certain threshold.

2. Promoting Healthy Lifestyles

Wearable devices also encourage users to adopt healthier lifestyles by providing real-time feedback on physical activity, sleep patterns, and calorie intake. Many devices come with integrated apps that set fitness goals, remind users to stay active, and provide tips for maintaining a balanced diet. By promoting healthy habits, wearables can help prevent the onset of lifestyle-related diseases such as obesity and type 2 diabetes.

3. Integration with Healthcare Systems

The data generated by wearable devices can be integrated with digital health records, providing healthcare providers with a more comprehensive picture of a patient’s health. This data can be used to personalize treatment plans, monitor patient progress, and intervene early in the case of potential health risks. For example, a doctor treating a diabetic patient could use data from the patient’s wearable device to adjust their medication or recommend lifestyle changes based on real-time blood sugar levels.

4. Government Initiatives and Public Health Programs

Wearable technology also has the potential to be integrated into public health programs in India, particularly those focused on preventive healthcare. For example, government

initiatives such as the National Health Mission or Ayushman Bharat could incorporate wearable technology to monitor the health of vulnerable populations in real-time. By deploying affordable wearable devices in rural areas, these programs could track key health indicators such as blood pressure, blood sugar levels, or heart rate, allowing for timely interventions and reducing the strain on overburdened healthcare facilities.

5. Overcoming Challenges in the Adoption of Wearable Technology

Despite the significant potential of wearable technology in improving preventive healthcare in India, several challenges must be addressed to ensure widespread adoption, particularly in rural and economically disadvantaged areas.

Cost and Affordability

Most wearable devices, such as fitness trackers and smartwatches, are relatively expensive for the average Indian consumer, particularly in rural areas where disposable incomes are low. While the cost of wearable technology is gradually decreasing, making these devices more affordable for the masses remains a key challenge. Public-private partnerships, government subsidies, or programs that offer devices at discounted rates to vulnerable populations could help overcome this barrier.

Digital Literacy and Usability

Many people in rural areas may lack the digital literacy required to use wearable devices effectively. Training and awareness campaigns aimed at educating both healthcare providers and patients on the use of wearable technology could increase its adoption. Additionally, simplifying user interfaces and offering wearable devices in multiple regional languages could make them more accessible to non-English-speaking populations.

Data Privacy and Security Concerns

As wearable devices collect sensitive health data, ensuring the privacy and security of this information is crucial. Many users may be concerned about how their health data is being used and whether it is adequately protected. The development of robust data protection regulations, such as India’s Personal Data Protection Bill, could help address these concerns by establishing clear guidelines on data usage and safeguarding personal information.

Connectivity Issues in Rural Areas

For wearable devices to transmit data to healthcare providers or integrate with electronic health records, a reliable internet connection is necessary. In rural India, where internet connectivity can be inconsistent or non-existent, the full potential of wearable technology may not be realized. Initiatives to improve internet access in rural areas, such as the BharatNet project, will be crucial for the successful adoption of wearable devices.

Case Studies: The Impact of Technology in India’s Healthcare Revolution

Several successful implementations of technology in India’s healthcare system provide valuable insights into how these innovations are transforming healthcare delivery across the country.

1. Aravind Eye Care and AI-Powered Diagnostics

Aravind Eye Care, one of India’s largest eye care providers, has adopted AI-powered diagnostic tools to screen patients for conditions like diabetic retinopathy and cataracts. Using AI algorithms to analyse retinal images, the system can detect early signs of eye disease and recommend treatment, even in remote areas where trained ophthalmologists are unavailable. This has significantly expanded access to eye care in rural regions, where eye health is often neglected due to a lack of specialists.

2. Apollo TeleHealth and Telemedicine

Apollo TeleHealth has been a pioneer in bringing telemedicine to rural and underserved communities across India. Through its telemedicine network, patients in remote areas can consult with specialists in urban centers, access diagnostic services, and receive prescriptions without leaving their homes. Apollo’s telemedicine model has been particularly effective in areas where healthcare infrastructure is lacking, demonstrating the potential of virtual consultations in bridging the healthcare gap.

3. Wearable Technology for Maternal Health

In several pilot programs across India, wearable devices have been used to monitor the health of pregnant women, particularly in rural areas. These devices track vital signs such as heart rate, blood pressure, and foetal movement, alerting healthcare workers to potential complications early on. This data is integrated with digital health records, enabling doctors and midwives to provide more personalized care. The use of wearable technology in maternal health has been shown to reduce the incidence of complications and improve outcomes for both mothers and newborns.

The Future of Technology in India’s Healthcare

As India continues to invest in healthcare infrastructure and technology, the potential for further advancements is immense. Several key trends are likely to shape the future of healthcare in India.

1. Expansion of Telemedicine Networks

Telemedicine is likely to become a permanent fixture in India’s healthcare landscape, with more healthcare providers adopting virtual consultation platforms. The government’s continued support for telemedicine, along with improvements in internet connectivity, will enable even the most remote communities to access quality healthcare. Future innovations in telemedicine may include the use of augmented reality (AR) and virtual reality (VR) for more immersive consultations and surgical training.

2. AI-Driven Personalized Healthcare

AI will play an increasingly important role in providing personalized healthcare in India. With AI-powered algorithms becoming more sophisticated, healthcare providers will be able to offer individualized treatment plans based on a patient’s genetic makeup, lifestyle, and medical history. This will be particularly valuable in managing chronic diseases, where AI can help identify risk factors and suggest interventions before symptoms worsen.

3. Integration of Wearable Devices with Public Health Programs

Wearable technology is poised to become a key component of India’s public health initiatives, particularly in preventive healthcare. By integrating wearable devices with government health programs, such as Ayushman Bharat, India can monitor the health of large populations in real-time, allowing for timely interventions and reducing the burden on healthcare facilities. As wearable technology becomes more affordable, its adoption is expected to increase, particularly in rural areas.

4. Digital Health Ecosystems

India’s healthcare system is moving towards a more integrated digital health ecosystem, where telemedicine, AI, EHRs, and wearable devices work together to provide seamless, patient-centered care. The National Digital Health Mission (NDHM) aims to create a unified platform for all healthcare services, making it easier for patients to access care, share their medical records, and receive personalized treatment. The NDHM’s success will depend on continued investment in digital infrastructure, training, and awareness campaigns to ensure that both patients and healthcare providers can fully utilize these technologies.

Global Adoption of Healthcare Technologies: Where Major Countries Stand

The healthcare technology revolution is not unique to India. Around the world, major countries and economies are adopting telemedicine, AI, digital health records, and wearable technology at various scales, contributing to more efficient and accessible healthcare systems.

1. The United States

The U.S. has been a global leader in healthcare innovation, particularly in the adoption of telemedicine and AI. Major hospitals and healthcare networks have integrated AI-driven tools for diagnostics, predictive analytics, and personalized medicine. Telemedicine gained significant momentum during the COVID-19 pandemic, with platforms such as Teladoc and Amwell providing remote healthcare services to millions of Americans. The U.S. is also home to tech giants like Google Health and Apple Health, which are pioneering the development of wearable technologies and health apps.

– Telemedicine: Widely adopted across the healthcare system, including integration with insurance providers for reimbursements.

– AI in Healthcare: Being used for diagnostic imaging, predictive analytics, and drug discovery.

– Wearable Technology: A significant portion of the population uses devices like Fitbit, Apple Watch, and other health-monitoring wearables for fitness and chronic disease management.

2. The European Union

Countries in the European Union (EU) have also embraced healthcare technology, particularly in the fields of telemedicine and digital health records. France, Germany, and the Nordic countries have invested heavily in building healthcare infrastructures that integrate telemedicine with national health services. The EU has also been proactive in implementing regulatory frameworks for data privacy and AI, balancing innovation with ethical concerns.

– Telemedicine: Integrated into national health systems with government support, especially in countries like France, Germany, and the UK.

– Digital Health Records: The EU has developed initiatives such as the European Health Data Space to ensure seamless sharing of health data across borders.

– AI in Healthcare: AI is increasingly being used in healthcare systems for medical research, drug discovery, and diagnostics.

3. China

China is rapidly advancing in the healthcare technology space, especially in AI-driven healthcare services. Major Chinese tech companies, including Baidu and Tencent, have developed AI applications for diagnosing diseases, managing healthcare data, and improving hospital workflows. Telemedicine is also widely used in China, especially in rural areas where healthcare access is limited. The government has invested heavily in building the digital infrastructure required to support these innovations.

– AI in Healthcare: China is a global leader in using AI for disease diagnostics, particularly in oncology and cardiology.

– Telemedicine: China’s large population and geographic diversity make telemedicine crucial, and the government supports its widespread use, particularly in remote regions.

– Wearable Technology: Wearables are popular for health monitoring, with companies like Huawei developing advanced health-tracking devices.

4. Japan

Japan has been a pioneer in healthcare robotics and AI-driven elderly care solutions. With an aging population, Japan has focused on integrating AI and robotics to assist in elder care, hospital management, and patient rehabilitation. Telemedicine is increasingly being used to address the shortage of healthcare professionals in remote areas, and Japan is investing in wearable technologies to monitor the health of its elderly population.

– AI in Elder Care: AI-powered robots are widely used in hospitals and nursing homes to assist healthcare workers.

– Wearable Technology: Wearables are used to monitor the health of Japan’s aging population, with a focus on fall detection and heart monitoring.

– Telemedicine: Telemedicine platforms are increasingly used to serve remote and elderly populations.

Current Status of Healthcare Technology in India: Where Are We Now?

India has made considerable strides in adopting healthcare technologies, but the country is still in the early stages of widespread implementation compared to some of the more advanced economies. The COVID-19 pandemic has acted as a catalyst for the adoption of telemedicine and digital health solutions, but there are still significant gaps in infrastructure, training, and investment.

1. Telemedicine

India has made notable progress in the adoption of telemedicine, especially since the government issued telemedicine guidelines in 2020. Platforms like eSanjeevani and private providers such as Practo and 1mgare offering teleconsultation services, especially in urban areas. However, the reach in rural areas remains limited due to poor internet connectivity and lack of digital literacy.

2. AI in Healthcare

The use of AI in India’s healthcare system is still nascent, but there are promising developments in diagnostics and predictive analytics. Companies like Niramai (breast cancer screening) and Qure.ai (radiology diagnostics) are developing AI-driven tools to assist healthcare providers in early detection of diseases. However, the widespread use of AI is hindered by the lack of standardized healthcare data and concerns around data privacy and security.

3. Digital Health Records

The National Digital Health Mission (NDHM), launched by the Indian government, aims to provide every citizen with a digital health ID linked to their medical records. While this initiative has the potential to revolutionize healthcare delivery, the adoption of EHRs across hospitals and clinics is still limited. Many healthcare providers, particularly in smaller towns and rural areas, continue to rely on paper-based systems.

4. Wearable Technology

Wearable technology is gaining popularity among urban, tech-savvy populations in India, particularly for fitness and wellness tracking. However, the penetration of wearables in rural areas remains low, primarily due to the high cost and lack of awareness. The potential for using wearable devices in preventive healthcare is vast, but India is still at an early stage of adoption.

Investment Requirements: Scaling Healthcare Technology in India

For India to fully realize the potential of healthcare technologies, significant investments will be required at both the national and individual levels. These investments span hardware, software, and training, as well as the infrastructure needed to support these technologies, such as reliable internet access and electricity supply.

1. National Level Investment

At the national level, implementing telemedicine, AI, and digital health records at scale will require a multi-faceted approach, with investments in both public and private healthcare infrastructure. Key areas of investment include:

– Telemedicine Infrastructure: Upgrading internet connectivity, particularly in rural areas, is critical. BharatNet, the government’s broadband initiative, aims to provide high-speed internet to rural areas, but additional investments in mobile network infrastructure and power supply will be needed.

– Estimated Investment: BharatNet alone requires an investment of approximately ₹42,000 crore (USD 5.7 billion). Expanding telemedicine platforms across the country will likely require further investments of at least ₹10,000 crore (USD 1.35 billion) for hardware, software, and training.

– AI in Healthcare: AI-driven diagnostics and predictive analytics require investments in data infrastructure, such as cloud storage, machine learning models, and data security. Additionally, partnerships with AI startups and research institutions will be necessary to drive innovation.

– Estimated Investment: To scale AI solutions across public and private hospitals, India may need to invest upwards of ₹20,000 crore (USD 2.7 billion) over the next decade.

– Digital Health Records: The NDHM is expected to cost around ₹500 crore (USD 67 million) in its initial phase, but the broader rollout of EHRs across public and private healthcare facilities could require up to ₹5,000 crore (USD 675 million).

– Wearable Technology: Public-private partnerships could help subsidize the cost of wearables for vulnerable populations, particularly in rural areas, where the adoption of preventive healthcare technologies could have a significant impact. A large-scale rollout of wearable devices as part of public health initiatives could require investments of around ₹1,000 crore (USD 135 million).

2. Individual Level Investment

At the individual level, the cost of adopting healthcare technology varies based on the type of device or platform. For patients to use telemedicine, AI-driven diagnostics, or wearable technologies, they will need to invest in the following:

– Smart Devices for Telemedicine: A basic smartphone capable of supporting telemedicine apps costs between ₹5,000 and ₹10,000 (USD 67 to USD 135), while higher-end smartphones with better internet connectivity and features can cost upwards of ₹20,000 (USD 270).

– Wearable Devices: Basic fitness trackers are available for around ₹2,000 (USD 27), but more advanced wearables with health-monitoring features, such as smartwatches, can range from ₹10,000 to ₹30,000 (USD 135 to USD 405).

– Data Plans: Internet data costs in India are relatively low, with monthly plans starting at ₹199 (USD 2.7). However, for continuous monitoring and telemedicine consultations, higher data plans may be needed.

-Training Costs: Healthcare providers and patients will require training to use new technologies effectively. Training programs for healthcare workers to use EHRs and AI tools could cost between ₹5,000 and ₹20,000 (USD 67 to USD 270) per provider, depending on the complexity of the system.

Conclusion: Path Forward for India

India is poised to make significant strides in its healthcare revolution by leveraging technology, but scaling these solutions across the country will require substantial investments in infrastructure, training, and public awareness. While major countries have already made significant advancements in integrating telemedicine, AI, and wearable technologies into their healthcare systems, India is still in the early stages, particularly in rural areas.

The key to India’s success lies in addressing infrastructure gaps, such as internet connectivity and power supply, while also making technology affordable and accessible for its large and diverse population. Investments at both the national and individual levels will be crucial in enabling the widespread adoption of telemedicine, AI, digital health records, and wearable technology.

With the right approach, India has the potential to not only revolutionize its healthcare system but also become a global leader in the use of technology to deliver affordable, accessible, and high-quality healthcare. The road ahead will

References to support the information provided in the article:

1. National Digital Health Mission (NDHM) – Official website of the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India.

   – Link: [https://www.ndhm.gov.in](https://www.ndhm.gov.in)

2. Telemedicine Guidelines 2020 – Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India. 

   -Link: [https://www.mohfw.gov.in/pdf/Telemedicine.pdf](https://www.mohfw.gov.in/pdf/Telemedicine.pdf)

3. BharatNet Project – Bharat Broadband Network Limited (BBNL), Government of India.

   – Link: [http://www.bbnl.nic.in](http://www.bbnl.nic.in)

4. Niramai – AI-based breast cancer screening startup in India.

   – Link: [https://www.niramai.com](https://www.niramai.com)

5. Qure.ai – AI-driven radiology diagnostic solutions.

   – Link: [https://www.qure.ai](https://www.qure.ai)

6. Apollo TeleHealth – Telemedicine initiatives by Apollo Hospitals.

   – Link: [https://www.apollotelehealth.com](https://www.apollotelehealth.com)

7. Aravind Eye Care – Telemedicine and AI-powered diagnostic programs at Aravind Eye Hospitals.

   – Link: [https://www.aravind.org](https://www.aravind.org)

8. World Health Organization (WHO) – Telemedicine adoption and healthcare innovations globally.

   – Link: [https://www.who.int](https://www.who.int)

9. Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019 – Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, Government of India.

   -Link: [https://www.meity.gov.in/writereaddata/files/Personal_Data_Protection_Bill,2019.pdf](https://www.meity.gov.in/writereaddata/files/Personal_Data_Protection_Bill,2019.pdf)

10. Teladoc Health – Global leader in virtual healthcare and telemedicine.

    – Link: [https://www.teladochealth.com](https://www.teladochealth.com)

11. AI in Healthcare – Stanford University’s Human-Centered AI Initiative.

    -Link:[https://hai.stanford.edu/research/ai-healthcare](https://hai.stanford.edu/research/ai-healthcare)

12. Wearable Technologies in Healthcare – Research by the National Institutes of Health (NIH), USA.

    – Link: [https://www.nih.gov](https://www.nih.gov)

These references provide credible sources to validate the points discussed in the article.

You’ll Also Love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *